Legal Sidebar: U.S. Supreme Court Weighs Limits of State Climate Litigation
In our latest NC Chamber Legal Institute Sidebar, we’re examining a case before the U.S. Supreme Court that could reshape the role of state law in climate-related litigation and have broader implications for North Carolina businesses.
U.S. Supreme Court Weighs Limits of State Climate Litigation
Does federal law preclude state-law claims seeking relief for injuries allegedly caused by the effects of interstate and international greenhouse gas emissions on the global climate? That was the question that the U.S. Supreme Court took up in Suncor Energy (U.S.A.) Inc. v. County Commissioners of Boulder County. If you think this kind of environmental litigation is confined to Colorado, keep reading, as North Carolina has already seen a similar case.
On Oct. 5, the Court opened the new term with oral arguments in the case, which included a discussion over whether the Court has jurisdiction to review the dispute at this early stage. Although the lawsuit centers on greenhouse gas emissions, the Court’s decision could affect businesses across multiple industries, particularly those facing public nuisance and environmental litigation and could reshape the use of state law to address those complex environmental issues.
The case began in 2018, when Boulder County and the City of Boulder, Colorado, sued ExxonMobil and Suncor Energy, alleging that the companies contributed to climate change through fossil fuel production and sales while misleading the public about the environmental risks. The local governments seek compensation for damages allegedly caused by climate change, including increased wildfires, flooding, and droughts. In May 2025, the Colorado Supreme Court held that federal law does not preempt Boulder’s claims and allowed the case to proceed. The companies then sought U.S. Supreme Court review.
The crux of the dispute is whether local governments can use state tort laws to impose liability for harms allegedly caused by worldwide greenhouse gas emissions. The energy companies argue that climate change is inherently a national and international issue governed by federal law, and that allowing state-law claims to proceed could subject businesses to inconsistent legal standards across different jurisdictions. Boulder, meanwhile, maintains that its claims seek compensation for local injuries and allege corporate misconduct, rather than regulation of emissions, and that federal law does not eliminate traditional state-law remedies.
What Happened at Oral Argument?
The justices appeared divided over both the merits of the dispute and whether the Supreme Court should decide the case at this stage.
Justice Clarence Thomas raised the jurisdictional question at the outset, pressing counsel for both the companies and the United States on whether the Court has jurisdiction to review the Colorado Supreme Court’s decision. Because the state court’s ruling merely allowed the lawsuit to proceed past an early dismissal stage, several justices questioned whether the decision was sufficiently final to warrant Supreme Court review.
On the merits, the justices considered the balance between states’ traditional authority over tort claims and the federal government’s role in regulating interstate and international emissions.
The energy companies argued that allowing individual states to impose liability for worldwide emissions could effectively permit local juries to shape national energy policy through substantial damage awards. Their position drew questions about whether state-law damages claims necessarily constitute regulation of conduct outside a state’s borders.
Boulder countered that its lawsuit is about alleged corporate deception and compensation for local injuries, not an attempt to establish emissions standards. The justices examined whether those claims could realistically be separated from the broader production, sale, and consumption of fossil fuels that allegedly contribute to global climate change.
The United States participated in support of the energy companies, arguing that the federal government’s authority over interstate pollution and foreign affairs limits the ability of individual states to impose liability for global emissions.
The questioning highlighted the difficulty of drawing a clear line between permissible state-law remedies and lawsuits that effectively regulate conduct beyond a state’s borders. With Justice Samuel Alito recused, the case will be decided by eight justices. A 4-4 split would leave the Colorado Supreme Court’s decision in place and allow Boulder’s suit to proceed, without setting a nationwide precedent.
Why It Matters to North Carolina Businesses
The implications of Suncor extend beyond the oil and gas industry. The case raises fundamental questions about the extent to which tort law can be used to impose liability for conduct occurring across multiple jurisdictions, particularly when that conduct is already subject to extensive federal regulation.
Those questions are especially relevant to North Carolina, where environmental litigation has continued to test the boundaries of traditional tort theories, including public nuisance, and the appropriate role of courts in addressing complex environmental concerns.
The Town of Carrboro’s lawsuit against Duke Energy is one relevant example. In December 2024, Carrboro sued Duke Energy, alleging that the utility company misled the public about the effects of fossil fuels and contributed to climate-related damage suffered by the town. Like Boulder, Carrboro sought to hold an energy company financially responsible for local injuries allegedly resulting from global climate change. Unlike the defendants in Suncor, however, Duke is an in-state regulated utility, and it argued that the decisions Carrboro challenged were made by the General Assembly and the North Carolina Utilities Commission.
In February 2026, the North Carolina Business Court dismissed Carrboro’s lawsuit, concluding that the claims presented nonjusticiable political questions better suited for the political branches of government. The court determined that resolving the claims would require judicial involvement in complex national and international energy policy decisions.
Although the cases involve similar allegations, the legal questions are distinct. Suncor primarily concerns federal preemption and the constitutional limits of state authority, while the Business Court dismissed Carrboro under the political question doctrine. Nevertheless, the Supreme Court’s reasoning in Suncor could influence how courts approach future climate-related lawsuits in North Carolina, particularly those seeking to use state tort law to address global environmental harms.
The decision could also have broader implications for litigation over PFAS contamination and other environmental injury claims against chemical manufacturers, utilities, and other businesses. While those cases often involve more localized contamination and different questions of causation, they similarly raise concerns about the appropriate boundaries of public nuisance liability, the relationship between tort law and regulatory frameworks, and whether courts should be asked to resolve matters traditionally addressed through legislation and regulation.
For businesses operating across state lines, the stakes are substantial. Allowing individual states to impose liability for widespread environmental harm could create inconsistent standards, increase litigation exposure, and make it more difficult for companies to predict the legal consequences of otherwise lawful business activities.
We’re keeping our eyes on Suncor because of its potential implications for North Carolina’s legal climate and the broader use of state tort litigation to address complex public policy issues. Ultimately, the case could help define where state tort liability ends and federal regulatory authority begins.